Blog Layout

Are we replaceable? Will AI replace marketers?

This seems to be the question of the day… Will AI replace marketers?


So… I ask ChatGPT and this is what it said: (feel free to skip below for my summary)


“AI is unlikely to completely replace marketing, but it will certainly change the way that marketing is done. As with any major technological shift, there will be winners and losers. Those marketers who embrace AI and use it to their advantage will likely thrive, while those who resist or fail to adapt may struggle to keep up.


One of the biggest advantages of AI in marketing is its ability to analyze vast amounts of data and provide insights that would be impossible for humans to uncover on their own. This can help marketers to better understand their target audience, personalize their messaging, and optimize their campaigns for maximum impact.


However, AI is not a magic solution and it still requires human input and expertise to be effective. Marketers will need to have a good understanding of how AI works and how to integrate it into their marketing strategies. They will also need to continue to develop their own skills and knowledge in order to stay ahead of the curve.


In summary, AI will not replace marketing, but it will definitely change it. Marketers who embrace AI and use it to their advantage will be able to achieve greater success than those who do not.” - ChatGPT


Thanks, ChatGPT, for telling us all what we most definitely already knew…  In summary,  marketing will, for the long foreseeable future, require human input and expertise. 


However, what do AI and the influx of marketing tools mean for the marketing profession right now? 


Who is the next unicorn marketer of the future? 


I looked to Google for some of their thoughts and in this recent video
How Search AI is Changing Marketing an interview of four search marketing experts from May 4, 2023. While some of these items are somewhat contradicting for a 2:41 min video these five points really jumped out at me: 


Innovation and the Acceptance of Failure

The first key takeaway is really around the need for an increase in dedication to creating more “time to try change.” Google is endorsing this idea for the need for “time” and license to “try things.” For the masses of marketers, innovation is definitely the name of the game. However, time and “chance to fail” have been stripped away. In our recent study, 2022 State of Today's Marketing Department Survey, 81% of marketers surveyed felt that the demands put on the marketing team greatly increased since the pandemic. With increased demands, it is fair to say that the ability to take chances and try new things is greatly diminished. 


More Curiosity

The need for more curiosity within marketers has always been a basic tenant of marketers. However, keeping up with the Jones, including the newest idea coming at you from every angle of the company has, over time, overshadowed the ability to be curious. 


Even with AI, Strong Analytics

The third idea that jumped out of this video is that skills of the next marketer are going to be “data engineering, strategic creative planning, and really strong analytical abilities.” Strategy and data engineering typically are strengths that come from different parts of a team. I, for one, am always better when I have a strong data engineer by my side. It takes both kinds, but not necessarily a superhuman with both skills. 


Age-old Battle Between the Generalist and the Specialist

We continue to oscillate between the generalist vs the specialist. I continue to be leery of the role of the “generalist” (which, of course, I call myself). It still becomes a rabbit hole for many marketers. While it is important for us to know enough about each element of marketing when we are “good enough” in too many of these areas, we end up watering down our focus and the ability to keep up with the massive change within each marketing area. 


Always Strategy

Lastly, and most importantly, yes… The most important part of marketing is “strategy.” It is the ability for us to take what we see, analyze, and hear and put that into useable tactics. 


So Google… I am going to give your little video a thumbs up on clickbait because you hit all the right “keywords”, but thumbs down because you left us, marketers, exactly where we were before… confused! 


My summary of the above video, if I am allowed to have my own interpretation of it, is that as marketers the need for strong, free-thinking, chance-taking strategists is key to the success of a marketing program. 


By Sara Trifiro 25 May, 2023
How to create blogs that engage the buyer even when using AI as an aid.
By Sara Trifiro 24 May, 2023
Marketing is changing rapidly. How do these changes affect the marketing professionals? Take this quick survey and let us know your thoughts.
By Sara Trifiro 16 May, 2023
Just imagine we are looking to buy something new like… an air fryer… what do we do? First, we search for “best air fryers” and review the many pages of curated articles full of lists and comparisons. We also use social and messaging tools to reach out to friends asking them which version they like best. Then head to YouTube and, in addition to wasting countless hours watching videos on all the great things you might make in said air fryer, we manage to watch several comparison videos and reviews. We are lurkers (yes, a very technical marketing term) and we are using dark social to inform our buying decisions. Since the pandemic, we have changed the buying process and put it back into our own hands, at our own pace and in our channels of choice. Think about it… By the time you have made the decision to purchase, you basically have made the decision on which brand to buy. This is also true for most B2B buying decisions today. Yet, companies are still struggling to reframe their go-to-market strategy and meet the buyer where they are NOW. We need to embrace content and dark social and build the right tools to assist the lurking process. In case the term dark social is new to you… It is not a sketchy back alley where you might go to buy an air fryer off the back of a truck for a deep discount. Dark social is where we go to make informed decisions and help us work through buying decisions. Chatgpt defines dark social as: "Dark social refers to the phenomenon of social sharing and online interactions that occur through private channels or platforms that are difficult to track or measure. It refers to sharing content or links via private messaging apps, email, or secure browsing, rather than through publicly visible social media platforms. In dark social, the sharing and interactions are not easily traceable or attributable to specific sources." Dark social can be any platform that is difficult to track such as twitter, linkedIn, and YouTube. It could be a chat forum on Slack where people ask peers for their experience. Or searching outside google which can be done in many untraceable ways. Even Reddit is becoming an important place for B2B product and services discussions. So how should dark social and the lurker inform companies your buying journey? Here are some suggestions: Use content to aid in the lurkers buying process Yes, I realize that most companies are processing content at a feverish clip. With AI it seems this becomes so much easier. Yet, if half or more of the buyer's decision-making process happens in dark social, then how can you truly understand what they are consuming and what they need? As marketers, stay in contact with your clients. Ask them about the key issues that informed their buying decision. Host roundtables. Add “where did you hear about us” on your web form. OR… jump on to a sales call and learn real-time from your team. Review your content and make sure it matches up with what you are learning. Make sure your speak to the lurkers needs and are readily available where they might want them as they move down the path to a decision. Make sure you have the right influencers reviewing your products and services so that your buyer can make an informed decision. Respecting and understanding the lurkers process What do I mean by respecting the lurkers process? At a recent client of mine, to download a simple educational white paper, the prospect would get catapulted into a fast-paced buying campaign. The lurker just wanted some information. Now they are receiving daily emails about specials, marketing propaganda, and pitches to sign up for a sales call. Sure, there are always a few people ready to buy. However, the vast majority are still lurking. Go ahead and add them to your content mailing list, but give them the space to lurk. It's not more leads, or even better leads, it is ripe leads Many times sales is jumping in too soon! This is jarring to the buyer and equally as frustrating for the sales team. But it is not the sales’ fault. As marketers, we play the role of intermediary and should try and guide sales in at the right time. I realize we don’t always have that control as marketers. Partnering with sales to help them be most successful will ultimately save them time and most definitely increase their win rate. Engaging in dark social In addition to producing great content, find more ways to engage in the conversation. Go… play... lurk! Act like a buyer and go see what you can find. Read Reddit to see what's happening there. Ask questions. Then design a “client journey” that matches today’s current buying process. It may be longer and more complex yet there are many automation tools that can help you tailor the process to their individual needs. This can be tough for small, resource-constraint organizations. But there are some tools such as “chatboxes” on social that can respond to keywords or simple campaign builders in email programs. and, lastly... Stay informed As we marketers know, nothing stays the same for long. Watch trends and keep connecting with your target market. Unfortunately, the yearly or even semi-yearly client focus groups are no longer enough. Build quarterly or even monthly points of contact with clients into your yearly strategic plan. Engage with the sales team. Hear their struggles. When are they seeing success? These will give you oodles of information on what content is needed and when. Ultimately, the stronger the partnership between both departments, the better the buyer's journey will be.
Share by: